1
Well, what do we have here? My old flame trying to claim the treasure I rightfully stole.
[M4F] [Historical] [Pirates] [Enemies to Lovers] [Exes] [Sword Fighting] [Competitive] [Negotiating] [Kissing] [Oral] [Riding] [Betrayal] [Handjob] [Blowjob] [Feral] [Growling] [Penetration] [Finish Inside]
20:184,933 Plays
3
I don't like the night watch either, but here we are, stuck together for the night.
[M4F] [Historical] [Pirates] [MDom] [Crewmates] [Bickering] [Angry Sex] [Bondage] [Fingering] [Hold the Moan] [Gagged] [Rough] [Praise] [Penetration] [Finish Inside] [Vaguely Scottish Accent] [Aftercare]
22:1914,004 Plays
5
If you plan to play double agent, you'd better be ready to ride the riptide.
[M4F] [MDom] [Historical] [Pirates] [Captain] [Spy] [Caught] [A Deal] [Teasing] [Kissing] [Rum] [Praise] [Degradation] [Oral] [Cunnilingus] [Good Girl] [Penetration] [Hair Pulling] [Rough] [Blowjob] [Finish Inside]
36:0913,924 Plays
Featured Creators
More Playlists Like This
Audios that play into this fan-favorite trope. Fake dating, but real feelings.
Your Plus One
drRapture · 7,462 PlaysWhat Should Have Been
UselessTimidityVA · 30,315 PlaysThere's Nothing Fake About You
Behold the Beauty · 4,302 PlaysIn honor of National Poetry Month, here are Audios that express love and romance in writing.
Taking Our Thyme
Lux · 2,572 PlaysA Soldier's Letter
Lost Tapes · 1,955 PlaysPoetry Section
Benjamiinc · 10,301 PlaysNo need to be smooth or suave—sometimes the best stories are a little clumsy.
Spilt Coffee Extra Creamer
Christian Sanford · 19,985 PlaysFemme & Flustered Again
Amanda Marie · 3,893 PlaysNot One for Parties
Chris Yamez · 24,126 Plays© 2025 Quinn, Inc. All Rights Reserved.